Mjengo Corporate logo
Compare

Custom software vs off-the-shelf software: which should your business choose?

Choose off-the-shelf software when your process is standard and a ready-made tool already fits it, such as accounting or email. Choose custom software when your workflow is what makes you money, when you are paying for many tools that do not talk to each other, or when per-user fees exceed the cost of owning a system.

Updated

Custom vs off-the-shelf software compared
CriteriaOff-the-shelfCustom software
Time to startSame day to a few days4–8 weeks for a typical business system (Mjengo Corporate)
Upfront costLow; often a free trialFrom KES 150,000 (≈ US$1,160) at Mjengo Corporate
Ongoing costMonthly fee per user or branch, rising with growthHosting and optional support; no per-user licence
Fit to your processYou adapt to the toolThe tool follows your process
Kenyan integrationsVaries: M-Pesa and eTIMS support not guaranteedBuilt in where needed: M-Pesa, SMS, eTIMS, banks
Ownership of data and codeVendor's platform and export limitsYou own it
RiskVendor changes price, features or shuts downDepends on the quality of the team you hire

When is off-the-shelf software the right choice?

Ready-made software is usually the better choice when:

  • The process is the same in every business: accounting, payroll calculations, email, file storage.
  • You are still testing the business and do not yet know what your workflow will be.
  • A well-supported product already handles M-Pesa and any compliance you need.
  • The total subscription cost stays modest as you grow.

There is no prize for building what you can rent cheaply. We regularly tell people to use an existing tool.

When does custom software pay off?

Custom software earns its cost when:

  • Your workflow is your advantage. A salon paying stylists by commission, an ISP reconnecting subscribers on payment, a distributor with tiered wholesale prices: generic tools force workarounds.
  • You run on spreadsheets and WhatsApp. If staff copy data between three tools every day, one system that does the job end to end saves hours and errors.
  • Licences scale badly. Per-user or per-branch fees across 20 staff and five branches can exceed the one-off cost of a custom system within a year or two.
  • You need it to talk to Kenyan systems. M-Pesa confirmations, bank settlement, bulk SMS and KRA eTIMS are first-class requirements here, not add-ons.

Netily, our own ISP billing system, exists for exactly this reason: generic billing tools did not reconnect subscribers automatically when they paid by M-Pesa.

How do cost and timeline compare in Kenya?

Using Mjengo Corporate's own starting prices:

  • UI/UX blueprint (test the system before building): from KES 25,000, 1–2 weeks.
  • Custom business system (POS, HRMS, ticketing, salon and barber, inventory): from KES 150,000 (≈ US$1,160), 4–8 weeks.

To compare fairly, add up three years of the off-the-shelf option: subscription × users × branches, plus the staff time spent on workarounds. Then compare that with the custom build plus hosting and support.

A middle path: off-the-shelf plus custom integration

It is not always either/or. Often the best answer is to keep a good ready-made tool for the standard part (for example, accounting) and build a small custom layer for the part that is unique: an M-Pesa reconciliation service, a customer portal, or a dashboard that pulls data from several tools.

Decision checklist

  1. Write your core workflow as steps. Does a ready-made tool handle every step without workarounds?
  2. Does it support M-Pesa and any compliance you need, such as eTIMS?
  3. What will it cost in three years at your expected number of users and branches?
  4. Can you export all your data if you leave?
  5. If you go custom, will you see and test a prototype before paying for the build?

If you answer "no" to the first two and the three-year cost is high, custom is worth scoping.

Frequently asked questions

Is custom software more expensive than off-the-shelf software?

Upfront, yes. Over time, not always. Off-the-shelf tools charge monthly per user or branch, so costs grow with the business; custom software has a one-off build cost plus hosting and support. Compare the three-year totals.

How long does it take to build custom business software in Kenya?

At Mjengo Corporate a typical custom business system takes 4–8 weeks after a 1–2 week UI/UX blueprint stage, depending on the number of user roles and integrations.

Who owns the code in a custom software project?

It should be you. Confirm in the contract that the source code, data and accounts (hosting, domains, app stores) are owned by your business on final payment.

Keep reading

Blueprint first

You see and test your product before we write a line of code.

Tell us what you are building. Within a week you can be clicking through a prototype of it, with a fixed price for the build.